Ringu or The Ring?!?

[SoUl SuRvIvOrS]

Damn I must have missed this thread...RINGU in my opinion was more suspenseful then the Ring..liked the Ring but loved Ringu..:D

[_Leatha_Face_]

well i voted for the Ring being that i havent seen Ringu;)

[allmykids]

i loved the ring. the phone rang just before i shut off the movie, no shit. made it a little creepyer for me.

[Tony]

I liked Ringu better simply because there were fewer plot holes. I'm sure we will see similar posts to this whey the "Eye" remake comes out.

[FangoFan]

If you don't reading and watching Ringu is, far scarier.
The Ring is good but Ringu is I think a classic

[xGuardianx03]

I just watched Ringu last night and I thought it was better than it's American counterpart. Of course alot of the creepy scenes lost their effect due to the fact I had already seen a version of them. The story seemed to be a little more complete and left fewer questions than did the American version.


opinions?

Before I start - I really hated the american verison of the film... (I wached Ringu first.)

Then to the point...

I think The Ring is to much effects and Too much Over-explanation... It seems they always have to fing some explanation to the problems. In Ringu, even though You do not have a lot of questions when the movie is over, it hasn't solved anything! :)

Another thing is that I feel that The Ring has combined features from both Ringu and Dark Waters, wich makes it very confusing! I do not think that the water on the floor has anything at all to do in the movie (Given that it is a Telepathic Killer... OK, it is a well in the story, but the well is just a toomb, nothing more.)

Lastly, I will never be able to understand why every kid in an american movie have to know everything!!! In Ringu the kid is just a kid :)

To sum up.

I am the proud owner of Ringu, as well as Ringu 0 and Ringu 2. When it comes to tThe Ring, I do not think I would bring it home unless someone paid me to take it off their hands... :S

Anyway, this is just my opinion, and luckyly tastes are wildely diffrent in the world.

Darkshade

[Hate_Breeder]

Ringu>The Ring

[zwoti]

ringu

[dantehorrorfan]

ringu