I'm going with this.......but a second viewing on both may change my mind.

It's probably because I'm not a batman fan

me either !

i'm a life long spiderman fan :D

No one mentioned Hellboy II.

Because I didnt see that one..... much to my dismay.

I didnt either, however I didnt enjoy the first one.

Shit, I forgot all about Hellboy II - deserves to be on the list for sure.

I'd rank them as follows:

1) Dark Knight
2) TIE - Iron Man + Hellboy II: The Golden Army
3) The Incredible Hulk

Even if you weren't fond of the first one, you should see Hellboy II. Of the 4 movies it has the best visuals, hands down. Simply stunning, and some of the actions scenes are badass beyond reason. The plot is a little bit thin in parts, but all in all it's just a really fun movie that's absolutely beautiful to watch.

I really enjoyed the first one, but the sequel kicks its little red ass.

i never think of Hellboy as a super hero guy ..

probably because he wasnt around when i was into comics

Hellboy2 wasn't up to the mark but i enjoyed that too. Surly TDK was the best and then comes Iron man & Incredible Hulk but I like to say that overall we are glad to have a superb year of excellent superhero movies (please don't count the filthy spoof Superhero movie on this!).

I lost all interest in hellboy 20 minutes into the first film.

I think they're too different to be compared to each other in any way other than what you'd rather watch again. For me it goes:

Dark Knight
Iron Man
Incredible Hulk

Each had faults and merits of their own. And though it was an excellent film, I have to agree with MD.